24 Buffalo Bills Gifts For Your Bills Mafia Dad is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More 

Buffalo Bills Gifts For Dad

Hey there, Bills Mafia offspring! If you’re on the hunt for the perfect gift to put a smile on your dad’s face, look no further. We’ve got you covered with a handpicked selection of Buffalo Bills goodies that will make your Bills-Loving Dad jump for joy. From tailgating essentials to cold-weather gear fit for a warrior, our guide of Buffalo Bills gifts for Dad will help you find the ultimate present!

Table of Contents

Best Buffalo Bills Gifts For Dad

These gifts are all roughly $40 to $150 and will help your Bills-loving dad enjoy the Bills and show off his fandom.

1. Tickets to a Bills Game!

Game tickets are a perfect gift for Dads who love sports and spending quality time with their loved ones. Get Dad some tickets and head down to Orchard Park and watch a Bills game.

2. Bills Jersey

A jersey from Fanatics is a fun gift for Dad to proudly show off his Bills fandom. Whether he’s watching the game at home or heading to the stadium, a jersey adds a touch of excitement and team spirit to their wardrobe. This one here is Josh Allen, but there is a whole variety of players to choose from.

3. BBQ Set

With a spatula, tongs, and grill fork, this Bills-themed BBQ set has all the essential tools needed for a fun and successful BBQ session, making it a unique and practical gift for Dad to bring to the tailgate or use on the grill at home.

4. Bills Button-Down Work Shirt

This royal blue button-down shirt is perfect for Dad to wear to the office. A fun way for Dad to look professional while also representing his beloved Bills.

5. Josh Allen Figure

This Imports Dragon NFL Josh Allen 6″ Figure is a fun gift for Dads who are Buffalo Bills fans. It brings the excitement of the NFL right onto their desk or table. Allowing them to fantasize about game-winning moments from Josh Allen.

6. Sports Memorabilia

Give your Dad the gift of nostalgia with autographed cards, footballs, or other valuables from the Bills players. These unique and sentimental gifts are sure to bring back fond memories of Dad’s favorite players of past teams.

7. Highmark Stadium Poster

Add a touch of class to any room in Dad’s home with this poster of Highmark Stadium. Perfect for season ticketholders or Dads that go to a lot of games, this work comes in various size options and finishing materials like Matte Poster, Metal Frame, Canvas, and Wood Print.

8. Bucket Hat

This Buffalo Bills Training Camp Stretch Bucket Hat in royal color is not only functional and stylish, but it also provides optimal comfort and UV protection. It’s the perfect gift for Dads who love to support their favorite football team while looking cool and staying protected under the sun.

9. Winter Jacket

This jackets stylish design, comfortable fit, and full-zip feature make it a fun and practical gift for Dads to showcase their team spirit while staying warm during a cold game in Buffalo.

10. Tailgate Cooler

This Soft-Sided Insulated Cooler Bag is a great gift for Dads who love tailgating. With a spacious 24-can capacity and available in various team options, it combines practicality with team spirit. Dad can keep his beers cold as he and the rest of the Bills Mafia are busy breaking tables! 

11. Ugly Christmas Sweater

This Ugly Sweater is a fun Christmas gift for Dads who love the Bills. Its unique design, featuring the team’s logo and a busy pattern, sets it apart from regular boring sweaters and brings a playful touch to the holiday season that they can wear to any holiday party.

Luxury Buffalo Bills Gifts For Dad

If you are looking to spend a little bit more money on a gift for your Bills-loving Dad, these next gifts are all priced over $150.

12. Bills Cornhole Set

This Buffalo Bills 2′ x 4′ Triangle Weathered Regulation Cornhole Board Set is a great gift for Dads who enjoy outdoor activities and friendly competition. It combines the benefits of a classic game with the added fun of representing their Buffalo Bills. Cornhole is a great game to bring to the tailgate for some friendly competition before kickoff!.

13. Bills Park Bench

The Buffalo Bills Park Bench is great for die-hard Bills fans. It allows them to not only show off their team pride in their own backyard or basement, but also provides a comfy and fun spot to relax and enjoy the game.

14. Buffalo Bills Wall Art

The Hex Head Buffalo Bills 3D Vintage Metal Wall Art is a fun gift for Dads who are die-hard football fans. Its unique design and authentic vintage look will bring a touch of nostalgia and team spirit to any man cave or home office.

15. Bills Golf Bag

This Buffalo Bills Birdie Stand Golf Bag is a fun gift for Dads who love golfing. It provides convenience and functionality with its lightweight design, insulated cooler pocket, and velcro glove and umbrella holder. Its spring action stand and padded handles ensure comfort and ease of use, making it an enjoyable and practical gift for any golf-loving Dad.

Affordable Buffalo Bills Gifts for Dad

If you’re looking for a less expensive gift for your die-hard Bills fan Dad, these gifts are all  $40 or less and will help Dad embrace his Bills Mafia fandom.

16. Football Holder Insulator Cooler

Looking for a gift that combines Dad’s love for football and his beverages? This Football Can & Bottle Holder is the perfect fun and functional gift that keeps his drink cool while he cheers on his favorite team.

17. Wireless Charger & Organizer

Not only does this desktop accessory wirelessly charge Dad’s devices, but it also has a little bin that helps keep their workspace tidy. The Buffalo Bills design adds a personalized touch that any Dad in the Bills Mafia would appreciate.

18. OH MY JOSH - Josh Allen Shirt

The “OH MY JOSH – Josh Allen Shirt” is a fun gift for dads who are die-hard football fans, especially those who admire the talented quarterback Josh Allen. This shirt allows them to proudly show their love for both their favorite team and their favorite player in a stylish and humorous way.

19. Blue Bills Hat

The Men’s Royal Buffalo Bills MVP Adjustable Hat is the perfect gift for Dads who are fans of the team, as it combines their love for the Bills with a stylish and adjustable hat that they can wear proudly in the car, at the beach, at the game, or on the golf course.

20. Pet Jersey

The Littlearth Bills Pet Jersey is a fun gift for Dog Dads who are Bills fans because it allows them to dress up their beloved furry friends in their beloved blue and white.

21. Wooden Bills Bottle Opener

Looking for a gift that combines Dad’s love for football and cracking open a cold one? This Buffalo Bills Wooden Bottle Cap Opener Sign is the perfect choice, allowing him to show off his team pride while easily opening his favorite beverages during game nights or backyard BBQs.

21. Customized Buffalo Bills Throw Pillow

Looking for a fun personalized gift for Dad? This Buffalo Bills Throw Pillow with a custom design can make for an affordable and thoughtful gift. You can put his name and favorite number or his favorite player’s name and number. 

22. Flip Flops

These NFL athletic gel flip flops are the perfect gift for Dads who love the comfort and support of gel sandals, and are avid fans of the Buffalo Bills. With their team logo proudly displayed on the slides, it adds a fun and spirited touch to their casual wear, making them the ultimate gift for the pool, beach, or lounging around the house on game day.

23. Bills Flag

The Buffalo Bills Large 3×5 Flag is a fun gift for Dads who are die-hard NFL fans. Dad can proudly fly this flag from his car, porch, or flagpole and show off his team pride. Plus, the high-quality construction ensures it can withstand outdoor elements, making it a great gift.

24. Insulated Tumbler

The Buffalo Bills Officially Licensed NFL Tumbler is a fun gift for Dads who love football, as it combines their passion for the sport with a practical and stylish insulated stainless steel cup. Dad can keep his coffee nice and warm while showing off his team pride with this tumbler.

Be the MVP of Dad's Special Occasion!

From their legendary tailgating traditions to braving the elements in true warrior fashion, Bills fans are a force to be reckoned with. 

But hey, if you didn’t quite find what you were looking for here, for your Bills Loving Dad, fear not! Poke around the rest of our site! We have countless resources to help you find the ultimate gift for your Dad.